How we rank renovation companies
Every guide on this site answers one question for one kind of project, such as a co-op kitchen on the Upper West Side or a brownstone gut renovation in Brooklyn. A good firm for one of these can be the wrong firm for another, so we don't publish a single "best contractor in New York" ranking.
1. Which companies we consider
We start with the companies New Yorkers are most often pointed to for the project in question: the names that come up again and again in local recommendations, guides and search results. From that pool we keep companies that clearly do this kind of work and serve the area the guide covers.
2. What we check
- Licensing. New York City requires a Home Improvement Contractor license for most residential renovation work. Where a company publishes its license number, we look it up in the city's public license records (Department of Consumer and Worker Protection). For New Jersey, contractors need a state Home Improvement Contractor registration.
- Relevant work. Published projects, building types and neighborhoods the company shows on its own site.
- Process. What the company says it does about board and building approvals, permits, written proposals, change orders, schedules and warranties.
- Fit. Whether the company designs and builds (design-build), builds from an architect's or designer's drawings, or focuses on kitchens and baths.
3. How we order a list
Order reflects fit for the project on that page. A firm can be first on one list and fifth on another. Every entry says who the firm is best for, so you can skip straight to the ones that match your project.
4. What we don't do
- We don't publish prices for specific companies. Renovation prices in New York depend on scope, finishes and building requirements.
- We don't guarantee any company's work. Always check the license, insurance and references, and get a written, itemized contract.
5. Updates and corrections
We review each list regularly, and the date at the top of every guide shows when it last changed. Companies change their services, licenses and addresses, and we update the lists when they do.